Understanding Surrender Charges: The Hidden Cost of Cashing Out Your Annuity Early

When you purchase an annuity or a life insurance policy, you're entering into a long-term financial contract designed to provide growth and security over time. While you may have the best financial intentions, life is unpredictable.

You may come across a situation in which you need funds from your annuity sooner than you expected. If this happens, it's important to understand the implications behind your withdrawal and how much you could pay in surrender charges.

The basics of surrender charges

Surrender charges are fees that insurance companies make when a policyholder decides to withdraw funds or terminate their contract before the term is up. The term, known as the surrender period, is a specified time frame in which you may incur surrender charges if you withdraw some or all of your money.

These charges can be detrimental to your overall investment if you aren't aware of them. If you surrender your policy preemptively, you could also trigger a tax event. Whether you're considering contributing to an annuity or already have one, understanding the implications behind surrender charges is vital to getting the most out of your finances.

How surrender charges work

It's important to understand each aspect of surrender charges and how you should navigate them to avoid penalties and optimize your retirement.

Calculation and structure

Surrender charges are usually calculated as a percentage of the policy's value at the time of surrender. The specific surrender charge depends on your policy. Commonly, an annuity or life insurance policy fee structure is higher in the early years of the contract, with a steady decrease over time.

For example, a policy might impose a 10% surrender charge if you withdraw money within the first year, but it could then decrease by 1% for every following year. This sliding scale is designed to discourage you from withdrawing your funds too early, allowing your assets to accumulate during the contract.

Insurance companies impose these charges to disincentive their policyholders from early withdrawals and to recoup some of the costs associated with managing, holding, and breaking the contract. As time passes, the policy becomes more profitable to the insurer, allowing them to decrease their surrender charges.

Impact on policyholders

Surrender charges can have an impact on your policy. If you have an annuity worth $100,000 and need to surrender it within the first year, a 10% surrender charge would cost you $10,000. Even if the fee decreases over time, it can still have a significant impact on your return. The bigger your annuity or life insurance policy, the bigger the fee can be. If your policy is $500,000, even 5% is $25,000.

The financial impact isn't only limited to the surrender charge. Surrendering a policy early can lead to missed opportunities for growth and income within the policy itself. Annuities and life insurance policies are financial products designed for the long term and typically provide the most benefit further down the road. By cashing out early, you could lose potential earnings that the annuity or life insurance policy would have accrued had it been held longer.

Tax implications of surrendering a policy

Surrendering an annuity or life insurance policy is more than paying surrender charges. It can come with significant tax consequences, which you should take into consideration before making a decision. These tax implications can impact the overall financial outcome of your decision to cash out early.

Taxation on earnings

When you surrender an annuity or life insurance policy, any earnings or interest accrued within the policy becomes taxable as ordinary income. This means that the amount of money you receive beyond your initial contribution or premium payments will be subject to federal income tax at your current tax rate. For example, if you have a deferred annuity that has grown in value over some years, the earnings portion of the payout will be taxed when you surrender the policy.

It's important to remember that tax isn't implemented over several years as it might be with regular annuity payments. Instead, the tax is levied all at once. This could push you into a higher tax bracket and cause you to pay more in taxes.

Early withdrawal penalties

Surrendering an annuity before you reach the age of 59 and 6 months can trigger an additional 10% early withdrawal penalty on the earnings portion of the payout. This penalty is the same as the penalty imposed on early withdrawals from retirement accounts such as IRAs and 401(k)s. The penalty is in place to discourage using these long-term financial products as short-term sources of cash.

Exceptions and special circumstances

While they aren't common, there are a few exceptions to the 10% early withdrawal penalty. If you surrender your policy due to a qualifying disability, for example,, you might not have to pay the penalty. These waivers are specific and limited, so it's a good idea to familiarize yourself with them if you plan on withdrawing funds from your annuity early.

Alternatives to surrendering a policy

While surrendering an annuity or life insurance policy may seem like the best solution to get quick access to cash, there are a few alternatives that might save you from surrender charges and tax penalties.

Making a partial withdrawal

One of the easiest alternatives to surrendering your policy is to make a partial withdrawal. Many annuity contracts allow policyholders to withdraw a portion of their funds every year without triggering surrender charges. It depends on your specific policy, but if this is included in yours, it's a great way to get funds without needing to pay fees and penalties.

Some insurance companies offer a “free withdrawal” clause in which you can withdraw a specified percentage of your annuity's value every year without incurring any surrender charges. While avoiding surrender charges by using this clause, you might still incur a 10% fee on any earnings withdrawn before the age of 59 and 6 months. It's also important to keep tax implications in mind when making partial withdrawals.

Taking a loan against the policy

If you have a life insurance policy with cash value, another option is to take out a loan against the policy itself. Policy loans allow you to borrow against the accumulated cash value of your life insurance without triggering surrender charges or tax liabilities. The loan usually incurs some interest, but the terms are generally better than traditional loans since the insurance company can use your policy as collateral.

Taking a loan against the policy can be a solid way of getting cash quickly. However, any remaining unpaid balance can be deducted from the death benefit if the policyholder dies before repaying the loan. Before making a decision, it's important that you take all aspects into consideration.

The surrender period: How long it lasts and what it means

The surrender period is a key part of any annuity or life insurance contract. It directly affects your ability to access funds without incurring fees, so understanding it is the best way to make sure you stay on top of your finances.

What is the surrender period?

The surrender period is the time frame in which surrender charges apply if you decide to cash out your annuity or life insurance policy. This period usually starts the day you purchase the policy and, depending on the terms of your contract, can last anywhere from a few years to over a decade.

If you choose to withdraw funds during the surrender period, you will incur a surrender charge. Again, the fee is usually higher initially than at the end. The specific fee scheduling depends on your insurance policy or annuity contract.

How it affects a policyholder's decision

The length of the surrender period can play a huge role in your decision to either withdraw funds or terminate the policy entirely. A longer surrender period means that you may need to wait several years before you can access your money without penalties, which might not be ideal for everyone.

Making the right decision

While surrender charges can appear intimidating, navigating them is easier than it at first appears. Surrender charges during the surrender period are usually higher in the beginning than toward the end of the contract and can have a few exemptions.

Understanding the surrender charges behind your annuity contract or life insurance policy can help you make the right decision when contributing to your financial future.

MM202710-310313